Content warnings have become a common feature in books, particularly in works of fiction.
Content warnings alert readers to potentially sensitive or triggering content that may be present in the book, such as depictions of violence, sexual content, drug use, or other sensitive topics.
While content warnings have sparked debate in some circles, they serve an important purpose in helping readers make informed choices about what they read.
So, what are content warnings, and why do they matter?
Content warnings are brief notices that alert readers to potentially sensitive or triggering content in a book.
These warnings are placed at the beginning of a book or at the start of specific chapters or sections.
We’ve seen content warnings for movies and TV shows for years.
Content warnings can be specific, such as a warning for depictions of violence, or more general, such as a warning for “adult themes.”
The purpose of content warnings is to give readers the opportunity to make informed choices about whether or not to engage with the content in question.
Readers who have experienced trauma or have sensitivities to certain topics may find content warnings particularly helpful in avoiding potentially triggering material.
By providing content warnings, authors and publishers can help create a more inclusive and sensitive reading experience for all readers.
Content warnings do not exempt the author or work from critique.
While content warnings can be a useful tool for helping readers navigate potentially triggering material, they do not absolve the author of responsibility for the content they have created.
Works that include potentially sensitive content should still be subject to critical analysis and evaluation, just as any other work of literature.
Critique should focus on the quality and message of the content, rather than just the presence or absence of content warnings.
Ultimately, authors are responsible for the work they produce, and readers have the right to engage with that content and to offer criticism and feedback as they see fit.
That being said, analysing and critiquing work should not come at the expense of insulting the person behind it.
As a consumer of a piece of media (book, movie, TV show etc.) you’re allowed to express your opinions and share your experience about it — even if that means eviscerating the work itself.
Not every book, movie or TV show is for everyone, and that’s okay.
But insulting a creator as a person, no matter how much you dislike their work or disagree with their world-view, is completely unnecessary because it isn’t productive or helpful in any way.
Disliking someone’s work or disagreeing with their world-view is a normal and valid experience, and it’s okay to express those opinions in a respectful and constructive way.
But insulting someone as a person is not only incredibly rude and unhelpful, it causes real harm.
Rallying online groups can have grievous consequences.
We’ve seen this time and again.
Personal attacks, cyberbullying, harassment and even death threats (over something fictional!) all have serious consequences for the individual being targeted.
Insulting someone as a person distracts from any valid critiques or concerns that someone may have about their work or world-view, and can make it harder to engage in productive dialogue or make meaningful change.
And this goes for both readers and authors.
Because I’ve seen both sides cause harm here.
Authors are people too, with feelings, experiences, and perspectives that are shaped by their own unique circumstances and backgrounds.
Even if someone disagrees with their work or world-view, it’s important to treat them with basic respect and decency as human beings.
This can include focusing on the work or ideas being presented, rather than attacking the person behind them, and engaging in respectful and constructive dialogue that seeks to find common ground or understand different perspectives.
And likewise, the writers putting their work out into the world need to understand that this opens that work up to critical scrutiny.
But that doesn’t mean the criticism is about the creator of the work (or at least, as I said, it never should be personal as readers engage with the work, not with the person behind it).
And authors going after the people who present their opinions on the work is just not right.
Readers are allowed to have their opinions on the books they read.
Readers are allowed to leave whatever reviews they feel are honest to them.
No review ever warrants going after a reviewer, because reviews are for other readers.
Content warnings are like weather forecasts.
They…
- …provide advance notice of something that might impact you. With weather forecasts, this might be a storm or extreme temperatures, while with content warnings, it might be the presence of potentially distressing or triggering material in a piece of content.
- …help you prepare. For example, if there is a content warning about a violent scene in a movie, you might choose to skip that scene or watch the movie with a friend who can provide support. Similarly, if there is a weather forecast for a snowstorm, you might stock up on food and supplies or adjust your travel plans.
- …are not always 100% accurate. While weather forecasts and content warnings both aim to provide accurate information, they are not always 100% reliable. Weather can be unpredictable, and sometimes content warnings may not accurately capture the potential impact of a particular piece of content on an individual. In both cases, it’s important to use the information provided as a guide, but also to be prepared for the possibility that things may not go exactly as planned.
The responsibility of what you, as a consumer, choose to consume ultimately lies with you because you know yourself best and are the only truly qualified person to make that call.
In some cases, even if you don’t have a lot of triggers, you might just want to be able to check in with yourself before diving into a certain kind of story since the things you consume can and do affect your mood.
Content warnings in books serve an important purpose in helping readers make informed choices about what they read.
They can help create a more inclusive and sensitive reading experience for all readers.
By understanding the role and limitations of content warnings, we can engage with literature in a more thoughtful and nuanced way.
Want to get more out of reading books?
Grab this FREE guide on how to start a reading journal, complete with review templates, reading trackers and bingo sheets.
Understand yourself better as a reader, engage more with the books you read & make space for creative self-expression. Get it now!
“When Sasha Barrett gets bitten by a snake on a mission, her squad captain’s quick actions not only save her life, but also make her realise something she may have known all along…“
